|
||||||||
T H E F R E N C H C E N T R E F O R R E S E A R C H
A N D S T U D I E S O N T H E W O R L D E C O N O M Y The CEPII - Past CEPII Newsletters - PDF Format - Subscribe / Unsubscribe C O N T E N T S: FOCUS Bank Rescue in the US and in Europe
In mid-September 2008, Lehman Brothers, one of Wall Street champions, failed. After one year of muddling through, the credit crisis mutated and became systemic, jeopardizing the whole international banking system. The wholesale money market froze entirely when interbank loans came to a standstill. The liquidity crisis fed back on solvency risk because banks could not refinance their illiquid and doubtful assets. The huge co-ordinated injection of liquidity by central banks was not enough to restore confidence in banks. Governments had to acknowledge the urgent need to step in with a dual action: directly guaranteeing interbank loans, and strengthening bank balance sheets. There are many ways to back up bank balance sheets. The US started with the Paulson plan that was hotly debated in Congress and finally adopted in late September under the TARP (Troubled Asset Relief Program). The bold initiative was a mass buying of toxic securities built on subprime credit for an amount of $700bn by a public holding company run by the Treasury, supplemented by a blanket $3400bn of MMF (money market funds) liabilities. The idea was to reanimate a market for those distressed securities to enable banks to sell their troubled assets and write off their losses. In buying presently illiquid assets, the Treasury would set a floor price for investors willing to buy in their own in anticipation of a future price rise. However such a market solution raised thorny questions: what was the right starting price? Which assets to buy? Why not buying directly foreclosed houses to stop the slump in house prices? Furthermore, the implementation of the TARP was to take time before it could start operations. Indeed, time was of the essence. Bank problems deteriorated rapidly and spread to commercial banks and insurance companies, forcing US authorities to emergency measures. Instead of a consistent forward plan, they reacted in a piecemeal way. On September 17, the Treasury had to take on the huge insurance company AIG, buying 80% of its capital that swept off their former shareholders. One week later, another experiment involved the FDIC. The biggest savings bank Washington Mutual and the fifth commercial bank Wachovia had to be rescued in the same week using the same technique. The former was bought by JP Morgan Chase and the latter by Citigroup with the guarantee of a ceiling on the acquired banks' losses. All losses beyond the ceilings were taken by the FDIC. Therefore those rescues amounted to a sharing between privatization of profits for the acquirer and socialization of losses for the tax payer. Meanwhile, the banking crisis was spreading fast in Europe, letting governments, who had repeatedly denied its existence, unprepared. Governments responded separately and piece by piece. In late September, emergency actions that failed first and had to be renewed were undertaken to save two Belgian banks, Fortis and Dexia, and a German bank Hypo Real Estate. Europe looked in disarray when the British government disclosed the first comprehensive and consistent plan on October 8. The British plan looked beyond crisis management in laying out the basis for a new model of finance. On top of guaranteeing interbank credit, the UK government recapitalized four big banks, investing massively in ordinary shares more than in preferred shares, taking the majority of RBS and a minority control in Lloyds TSB and HBOS that are going to merge. Only Barclays kept some autonomy amongst the banks that requested government help. Furthermore the UK government requires a much higher level of tier 1 capital for the future, putting an effective end to unbridled leverage. Regarding the appalling state of governance in banks, the plan imposes sweeping changes. Trader bonuses and officer salaries will be curtailed. They should be driven by long-run value creation and make allowance for risk. Long-run management, high capital cushion and tighter internal risk control amount to the funerals of the investment bank model of credit. The British plan was heralded by the heads of state of the euro zone on October 12. Was it effectively adopted? Not at all as far as France is concerned. Instead of guaranteeing loans at the least cost, the Ministry of Finance invented a new public intermediary that will actually refinance bank credit. The state will recapitalize banks without any control whatsoever on bank management. Moreover the French plan offers no perspective neither on the model of banking, nor on bank governance after the crisis. Hence, it is based on quite different national approaches that advanced economies will participate in international discussions on how to fix international finance in a long-run perspective. Although there is broad consensus on specific points (such as correcting the pro-cyclical features of accounting standard), enhancing international cooperation on the design and implementation of financial regulations may prove as difficult as having the main economies conclude the Doha round or agree on a common, ambitious strategy to fight global warming. References: Whereas the financial crisis focuses all attention, the structural tensions on commodity markets are still underlying, especially concerning agricultural markets. The contribution of the recent biofuels development to the "silent tsunami" is still debated and embarrasses its promoters, mainly the US, the EU and Brazil. According to the US administration, contribution of biofuels production to the increase in food prices remains limited. On their side, international organisations defend more significant effects (over 50% for the IMF, 75% for the World Bank). However, most of the studies referred to avoid two important dimensions so far: (i) trade policy, especially for the European Union, plays a significant role in determining location for biofuels production; (ii) land use analysis is central to assess possibilities of future production and the extent to which food, feed and biofuels production are compatible.
On the basis of the trade policy model MIRAGE developed by CEPII (Decreux and Valin, 2007), we have built a specific model incorporating food production, land use change, agricultural prices, and trade policies at the world level in the same framework. Grounded on the general equilibrium theory, this model describes interactions between the different markets, in a world of limited resources (land and natural resources), and explicitly represents the role of different types of biofuels crops, as well as the role of energy demand and oil prices in the development of substitution fuels. Using this model, it is possible to compare the effect of various trade policy scenarios related to the objectives of the European Union on renewable fuels: mandates, liberalisation, and different schemes of subsidies. Results will allow to progress on the understanding of linkages between commodity prices, their effect on food security across the world, and their overall environmental impact, in terms of CO2 emissions as well as agriculture sustainability. Interest Rate Convergence: an International Comparison The increasing integration of international financial markets may have affected the behaviour of interest rates, from both a domestic and an international point of view.
The domestic question is the term structure of interest rates. According to the expectations theory of the term structure, the yields on financial assets of different maturities are related primarily to market expectations of future yields. The theory implies that the yield spread between the long rate and short rate is an optimal predictor of future changes in short rates. While many studies have explored this expectation theory, their results relating to the validity of this theory remain ambiguous. Turning now to the international question, interest rates are expected to move together across various countries, at least for some groups of countries, although interest rates convergence crucially depends on the exchange rate regimes. Our aim is to proceed to a detailed study of the interest rate convergence in the context of increasing financial integration. In order to implement a comprehensive analysis and to provide international comparisons, we consider five groups of countries: the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN) plus China, Japan and Korea (ASEAN+3); the group constituted by Australia and New Zealand Closer Economic Relationship (CER); the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) group; the Euro area and the European Union. Adeline Bachellerie, Jérôme Héricourt & Valérie Mignon Dutch Disease in a Two-Country Model with an Illustration to West African Countries The members of the Economic Community of the West African States (ECOWAS) have planned to form a monetary union by 2012. These countries are endowed with raw materials, minerals, plantation crops, gas, oil that they export and thus suffer from the so-called 'natural resource curse'. Although monetary union may happen not until 2012, it is worthwhile examining its implications for both WAEMU (West-African Economic and Monetary Union) and WAMZ (West-African Monetary Zone) countries. Specifically, the WAMZ is dominated by Nigeria, a large, oil-exporting country that may suffer from the Dutch disease; is there a risk of the Dutch disease spreading to WAEMU countries? What kind of exchange-rate regime (against the rest of the world) could alleviate this risk? Could a sovereign fund help?
We propose a DSGE, two-country Dutch disease model applied to the ECOWAS- region. Monetary policy is introduced through a money-supply behavior that is related to the exchange-rate regime, together with some nominal rigidities à la Calvo and a proportion of financially-constrained households. The role of a sovereign fund is carefully examined. The model is calibrated and simulated using the key structural characteristics of Nigeria and the WAEMU countries. We then simulate the impact of oil and other commodity price shocks depending on (i) the exchange-rate regime of the union vis-à-vis the rest of the world; (ii) the existence of a stabilization fund in Nigeria. We expect the Dutch disease to spread less from Nigeria to WAEMU in the presence of a stabilization fund. New Players in International Trade: Europe Facing the Challenge of Emerging Economies and Rentiers
Over the past ten years, advanced economies have lost ground in international trade in favour of new players, but up to now the EU-15 has resisted better than the US and Japan. The study investigates the reasons for this resilience and whether it is sustainable. First, it identifies and classifies the new players into two categories, "emerging economies" and "rentiers", according to the nature of their exports: manufactured goods, services, or primary goods. Then, it provides an in-depth analysis of EU trade with these new players based on Comext data.
The EU has considerably increased its trade with emerging countries and rentiers, which in 2007 accounted for 56% of its imports (excluding intra-EU trade) and 47% of its exports (against respectively 42% and 36% in 1995). The EU records a growing trade deficit with these new players, which is not compensated for by its trade surplus with advanced economies. EU's deficit with emerging countries stems from Asia, while the strengthening of regional ties with emerging neighbouring markets (Central and Eastern Europe, Mediterranean countries) has given rise to a trade surplus. The analysis of trade by stage of production shows that EU trade with emerging economies is increasingly driven by an international segmentation of production processes: EU's strongest position now lays in parts and components while its comparative advantage in investment goods is declining. By contrast, EU trade with rentiers provides evidence of strong traditional complementarity: in 2007, EU surplus in manufactured goods with these countries made up ¾ of its deficit in primary goods. Compared to the US or Japan, the EU has a relatively high trade intensity with rentiers, and is by far their major supplier. The study will assess the opportunities these countries represent for European business, compared to that of emerging markets. Turning to the composition of EU trade according to price/quality ranges, the study finds out that EU exports to emerging East Asian countries are strongly biased towards high-price/quality goods, while its imports from this region are biased towards medium- and high-price/quality goods. The reasons and the consequences of such favourable "terms of trade" for Europe will be investigated. TradeProd: a Consistent Database on World Trade and Production
In recent years, research in international economics has benefited from detailed and consistent data on bilateral trade volumes, industrial production and tariffs. In 2005 CEPII started to put these data together, building so a precious tool for measuring the globalization process, the industrial specialisation and labour reallocations between countries and industries. TradeProd combines data in a compatible industry classification: it extends the World Bank database (Trade, production and protection from Nicita and Olarreaga, 2006) and adds bilateral data on trade policy (tariffs and NTB) at the industry level. A new version is now available, which expands figures in production, provides bilateral trade based on new and highly disaggregated data: data are disaggregated at the ISIC(rev2) 3-digit industry level (28 industrial sectors) over the period 1980-2004 for production and bilateral trade, and 1989-2001 for bilateral protection data.1 Trade data come from BACI, the CEPII World Database of International Trade at the Product Level. BACI uses mirror flows (reconciled to warrant consistency), which increases trade data coverage, especially for developing countries. Over the whole period, 222 countries/territories are covered.2 Industrial data come from the UNIDO (number of firms, value added, number of employees and wages) and the OECD STAN Industry Database. The number of countries for which we have both trade and production data ranges from 31 in 2004 to 110 in 1993, with a mean of more than 93, depending on availability of data. The large set of countries and industries in the database covers a wide share of world trade and production, and allows comprehensive analyses of globalization process. Figure 1 Source: TradeProd.
Figure 1 shows clearly that world trade increased much more rapidly than world production during the last decades.
The high level of disaggregation in TradeProd allows more detailed analyses. For instance, Figure 2 shows, for each industry, the relationship between change in Asian and African countries' total exports between 1980 and 2000 and the evolution of their production during these twenty years. As expected, trade and production expand jointly in both regions. However, this relationship is steeper for Asian countries than for African countries. This simple fact illustrates how Asia succeeded better than Africa in taking advantage of globalization. Note that TradeProd is above all an accurate tool to describe the world economic geography and has been used for more academic research. For instance, Crozet and Trionfetti (2008) show how geographic proximity to world demand influences countries' specialization in increasing returns to scale industries. Mayer and Zignago (2005) use trade and production data to measure trade barriers to the access to Northern markets for Southern producers. Figure 2 Source: TradeProd. References: Crozet M. & Trionfetti F., Trade Costs and the Home Market Effect, Journal of International Economics, 76(2), 2008, pp. 309-321 Mayer T., Paillacar R. & Zignago S., TradeProd, The CEPII Trade, Production and Bilateral Protection Database: Explanatory Notes, CEPII Mayer T. & Zignago S., Market Access in Global and Regional Trade, CEPII Working Paper, N° 2005-02, January, 2005 Nicita A. & Olarreaga M., Trade, Production and Protection Database, 1976-2004, World Bank Economic Review, 21(1), 2007, pp. 165—171 1 http://www.cepii.fr/anglaisgraph/bdd/TradeProd.htm 2 http://www.cepii.fr/anglaisgraph/bdd/baci.htm Sixth ELSNIT Annual Conference on Integration and Trade International Migration: Trends and Challenges The Location of Japanese MNC Affiliates: Agglomeration, Spillovers and Firm Heterogeneity Tomohiko Inui, Toshiyuki Matsuura & Sandra Poncet Nonlinear Adjustment of the Real Exchange Rate Towards its Equilibrium Value: a Panel Smooth Transition Error Correction Modelling Sophie Béreau, Antonia Lopez Villavicencio & Valérie Mignon Demographic Uncertainty in Europe Implications on Macro Economic Trends and Pension Reforms. An Investigation with the INGENUE2 Model Michel Aglietta & Vladimir Borgy The Euro Effects on the Firm and Product-Level Trade Margins: Evidence from France Antoine Berthou & Lionel Fontagné The Impact of Economic Geography on Wages: Disentangling the Channels of Influence Laura Hering & Sandra Poncet Do Corporate Taxes Reduce Productivity and Investment at the Firm Level? Cross-Country Evidence from the Amadeus Dataset Jens Arnold & Cyrille Schwellnus Choosing Sensitive Agricultural Products in Trade Negotiations Sébastien Jean, David Laborde & Will Martin Government Consumption Volatility and Country Size David Furceri & Marcos Poplawski Ribeiro Inherited or Earned? Performance of Foreign Banks in Central and Eastern Europe Olena Havrylchyk & Emilia Jurzyk The Effect of Foreign Bank Entry on the Cost of Credit in Transition Economies. Which Borrowers Benefit the Most? Hans Degryse, Olena Havrylchyk, Emilia Jurzyk & Sylwester Kozak Contagion in the Credit Default Swap Market: the case of the GM and Ford Crisis in 2005 Virginie Coudert & Mathieu Gex Exporting to Insecure Markets: a Firm-Level Analysis Mathieu Crozet, Pamina Koenig & Vincent Rebeyrol Social Competition and Firms' Location Choices Vincent Delbecque, Isabelle Méjean & Lise Patureau Border Effects of Brazilian States Marie Daumal & Soledad Zignago CEPII Working Papers are available free, on-line, in PDF format.
ECONOMIE INTERNATIONALE, QUARTERLY
Jean-Yves Gnabo & Christelle Lecourt Shake Hands or Shake Apart? International Relationship of Japan with Global Blocs Toshihiro Okubo Vieillissement, retraites et ouverture financière en Europe : des réformes encore insuffisantes Xavier Chojnicki & Riccardo Magnani The Gravity of Institutions Cindy Duc, Emmanuelle Lavallée & Jean-Marc Siroën Trade, Human Capital, and Technology Diffusion in the Mediterranean Agricultural Sector Nadia Belhaj Hassine
LA LETTRE DU CEPII ,
QUARTERLY
Euro-Dollar: Face-to-Face N° 279, June 2008 The financial crisis that began during the summer of 2007 accelerated the depreciation of the dollar. Has the dollar now fallen far enough for global disequilibria to be reabsorbed and for a reappreciation to take place? What do the two methods commonly used to determine medium- or long-term equilibrium exchange rates tell us? The results they give differ, but they both indicate that the dollar and the euro are overvalued in real effective terms. The two currencies should therefore depreciate in relation to other currencies. The abruptness of the dollar's depreciation since summer 2007 might mean that the U.S. currency's current weakness will be relatively short-lived. As for the euro, its depreciation against other currencies is countered by the fact that it forms the main alternative to the dollar. Agnès Bénassy-Quéré, Sophie Béreau & Valérie Mignon American and European Agricultural Market Access: A Concern for The South? N° 277, April 2008 For years, the agricultural policies of the United States and the European Union have been the object of internal debate at the same time as they have been at the heart of agricultural discussions in the Doha round of WTO negotiations. The CAP (Common Agricultural Policy) is being examined in the framework of the "Health Check" and of the general review of EU community finances, the American discussions about the Farm bill are making no headway and the Doha round of negotiations is still blocked. The food crisis that has been developing over the last few months has put agricultural issues into the headlines again. A workshop on European and American agricultural policies took place last March, organised by Bruegel, the CEPII, the German Marshall Fund and the IFPRI. The CEPII presented the conclusions of its evaluation of the effects of opening the European and American agricultural markets to the developing economies. This Letter summarises the principle results of this work. Economic Partnership Agreements: The Impact of Trade Liberalisation N° 276, March 2008 The WTO rules of non-discrimination require a redefinition of the existing trade agreements between the European Union and the ACP countries. If they wish to retain preferential access to the European market, these countries and the EU will have to come to a reciprocal free trade agreement (EPAs) covering most of the bilateral trade. But uneven development creates a high degree of asymmetry between the two negotiating parties, accentuated by the current levels of protection which strongly concentrate the effort necessary to accomplish the liberalisation reform on ACP countries. In this article we evaluate the commercial and budgetary impact for each of the six ACP regions with whom the EU has been negotiating. For some countries, the transition will be difficult and will require sustained European support. Lionel Fontagné, David Laborde & Cristina Mitaritonna Understanding the Structured Credit Crisis N° 275, February 2008 The financial crisis which is raging in the West is quite strange. Why is it that repayment problems in a very particular segment of the United States housing finance market (subprime mortgages) has degenerated into a generalised credit crisis which could have completely paralysed the international bank liquidity market without the repeated and massive intervention of the central banks? To understand this we have to delve into the arcane world of the financial model called the securitization of debts which has become prevalent in the United States since 2001. Recent studies have shown that this model leads to reduced risk aversion on the part of lenders and to an under-assessment of the risk attached to loans. The spreading of risk, which is the purpose of securitization, is accompanied by a loss of information on the risk of loans right along the chain, from the end borrower to the buyers of tranches of secured debt. This financial model has become a loss generating machine. La Lettre du CEPII: a Chronicle of Globalization
N° 274, January 2008 1978-2008, CEPII is thirty years old! For La Lettre du CEPII, its four-page, monthly publication, it is an opportunity to look back over the thousands of pages published since its first issue.
Les pays émergents dans la tourmente
Les Etats-Unis dans la mondialisation
Grands et petits émergents à l'épreuve de la crise |
||||||||
| The contents of this Newsletter were finalised December 10, 2008 | ||||||||
|
||||||||